People who dont care what the meat they are buying is will just default to price and convenience i.e. Colesworth.
I dunno. I want this to be true but I find the meat pretty reasonable at both. You just have to shop the midrange.
Tbh as a bbq-er a butcher is almost wasted on me. I just want the cheap cuts for low and slow. The butcher advantage is you can get products you can't get at the supermarket (eg, bone-in pork shoulder). Still seems hard to find decent American style cuts at butcher's though - brisket packet or pork butt etc.
Otherwise I don't care for the crappy rissoles or "gourmet" sausages.
The other thing is that I rarely eat red meat. Ill have a t-bone now and then buy for my family out meat consumption is chicken and fish (and mince).
Maybe most butchers don't need to worry about the local consumer and just supply to restaurants?